Pepper Jack Cheese Substitute

Pepper Jack Cheese is a semi-firm cheese with a spicy flavor that comes from rosemary, sweet peppers, garlic, spicy jalapeños, and habañero chilies that are added to the curds. It is a spicy variation of the traditional American Monterey Jack cheese. If you are looking for a Pepper Jack Cheese substitute, we have a delicious choice of options for you. 

What is Pepper Jack Cheese?

Pepper Jack Cheese

Pepper Jack Cheese is a spicy variation of the traditional American Monterey Jack cheese. Jack Cheese was originally made by Franciscan monks in California. It has a semi-soft texture and a delicate flavor.

This cheese has a sharper taste as it is enhanced by the addition of peppers, garlic, rosemary, jalapeños, and chilies. As the cheese ages, the spicy flavor intensifies, and the cheese acquires a semi-firm texture and a creamy color.

Pepper Jack Cheese is great to eat on crackers as a snack. It will add a zingy taste to homemade hamburgers. Pair chunky slices of Pepper Jack Cheese with grapes, melon, olives, and pickled vegetables for a tempting cheese platter. 

Because the cheese melts easily, it is perfect for hot cheese sandwiches and makes a tasty topping for a nachos dish. 

Substitutes for Pepper Jack Cheese

Pepper Jack Cheese is used in many situations, so there are a few substitution options you can pick based on your needs and taste.

SubstituteTasteGood For
Havarti Cheese Mild, spicyPasta, Grilled Sandwiches
Cheddar CheeseStrong, matureSoups, Potato, Platters
Muenster CheeseTangy or mildBurgers, Pizza
Edam CheeseSalty, nuttyPasta, Casseroles

1. Havarti Cheese 

Havarti is a Danish cheese that offers a semi-soft springy texture and a mild but spicy flavor. Substituting it for pepper jack cheese will provide enough zing to tempt the taste buds. 

This cheese is made from the milk of Danish cows and takes on strong notes of hazelnut as it ages. The longer it is aged, the more flavourful it becomes. 

Most versions of Havarti cheese are free of gluten and are suitable for vegetarians. However, it is always advised to check the labels to make sure. 

Havarti cheese can be grilled, sliced, or melted. It adds a delicious twist to classic pasta dishes and makes a tasty grilled cheese sandwich. You can use Havarti cheese on a cheese-tasting platter as a softer option alongside harder cheeses. 

Make asparagus, Havarti quiche, or Havarti bacon and turkey burgers for something different. 

2. Cheddar Cheese

Cheddar cheese is one of the most popular household cheeses and can be used as a substitute for Pepper Jack Cheese. It is more creamy and less spicy but will do the job when you have run out of other options. 

This cheese originates from the Somerset region of England. It is made from cow’s milk and has a crumbly, hard texture. The color can vary from off-white to pale yellow or orange, depending on the colorants that are added. As cheddar matures, it takes on a sharper taste. 

Because it contains either animal or microbial rennet, Cheddar cheese is not suitable for vegetarians. For non-vegetarians, it is a great source of calcium for healthy bones and teeth. 

Cheddar cheese is great for slicing, dicing, melting, or grilling. It can be used in various dishes ranging from scones to biscuits, soups, stuffed potatoes, portions of pasta, and cheese platters. As a substitute for Pepper Jack Cheese, it is perfect for your Mexican quesadillas, spicy nachos, and hot grilled cheese sandwiches. 

3. Muenster Cheese

Some variations of Muenster cheese are flavored with onions and caraway seeds, giving them a tangy, spicy taste that makes a good substitute for Pepper jack cheese. Milder Muenster cheeses are a perfect substitute for people who like the texture of Jack cheese but prefer a more toned-down taste. 

Muenster cheese is an American version of the original Munster cheese, named after the Alsatian abbey of Munster in France.

Enjoy an ice-cold beer with sliced Muenster cheese on a hot day. For those cold winter meals, it is ideal for use in a classic macaroni and cheese dish. You can also add it to burgers, grill it in sandwiches and choose it for a unique flavor profile on pizzas. 

The cheese is made from pasteurized cow’s milk and is unsuitable for people who follow a dairy-free diet. 

4. Edam Cheese

When looking for a substitute for Pepper Jack Cheese, Edam cheese is a great option. It is a semi-soft cheese with a salty, nutty taste that becomes stronger as it ages. Well-matured Edam cheese is a definite choice if you are looking for that tangy replacement. 

Edam cheese originates from northern Holland and is easily recognizable by its flat-ended cylindrical shape and thick bright red wax coating. 

This cheese melts well and is delicious in pasta, baked potatoes, and baked egg casserole dishes, where it adds the piquant flavor you would get from Pepper Jack Cheese. You can also slice and dice Edam cheese and offer it as part of a cheese and wine tasting platter. It pairs well with the fruity taste of white Riesling wines. 

Offering low-fat content, it is great for weight watchers. Edam cheese is not suitable for vegetarians. 


Whether you are looking for a milder Pepper Jack Cheese substitute or have run out of your spicy treat at the last moment, you are sure to find a great substitute with one of the alternatives above. For a cheese that has a strong flavor, go with a well-matured cheddar or a spicy Muenster. For a less intense taste, a younger Havarti cheese is a good option. 

More about Pepper Jack cheese: